Three chief financial officers in one year. The last one, Ashlee Gabrysch, lasted three months before walking out the door rather than — her words — "compromise my integrity."
That's the financial leadership record of Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson. And now his own city council has seen enough.
The Chicago City Council voted 45-5 on November 19 to formally review Johnson's handling of the city's finances, as reported by Hot Air. Not a close call. Not a party-line squeaker. Forty-five aldermen — in a city where finding a Republican officeholder requires a search warrant — looked at the books and said we need a second opinion.
Downtown Alderman Bill Conway, who pushed the ordinance, framed it plainly: "We can't put our fiscal house in order until we know the foundation is sound. Regardless of whether you think there is misconduct or not, it is important that we conduct such a review in light of recent allegations."
The allegations are not subtle. Johnson proposed a $17.6 billion budget while staring at an $882 million shortfall. His administration claimed 76 percent of that gap was closed with structural fixes. Gabrysch — the CFO who quit — put the real number at 56 percent. That's a $200 million disagreement between the mayor and the person he hired to count his money.
It gets worse. Johnson wants to borrow $481 million to cover police-misconduct settlements, a plan that would cost taxpayers an additional $190 million in interest over seven years. Another $350 million in borrowing is proposed for 2027. Meanwhile, the city's four pension systems sit on $36.4 billion in unfunded liabilities, with taxpayers on the hook for a record $3.01 billion contribution next year.
Alderman Andre Vasquez offered a window into how the mayor's office is handling the scrutiny. Comptroller Michael Belsky, now serving as acting CFO after Gabrysch's departure, was described by Vasquez as someone who "was telling us he's not even allowed to talk to us, and he's worried about losing his job." The city's top financial officer afraid to speak to the city council. Belsky himself offered only this: "The proof's in the pudding. The ACFR is the scorecard of the budget."
The mayor's defenders will point out that every big city faces budget pressure. Chicago's budget grew 40 percent between 2019 and 2025. Federal pandemic money dried up. The spending didn't.
The DOJ has also reportedly taken interest in Johnson's own admission regarding the use of migrant funding — a thread that hasn't fully unspooled yet but adds another layer to the financial picture his council just voted overwhelmingly to examine.
Forty-five to five. His own council. In his own city. The aldermen who represent the same voters Brandon Johnson does just asked for a formal look at whether the numbers he's been giving them are real.
Three CFOs in twelve months. The last one said the job required compromising her integrity.