Democrat Civil War Breaks Out as Van Hollen Comes for Schumer's Gavel

0
Democrat Civil War Breaks Out as Van Hollen Comes for Schumer's Gavel

Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland announced Thursday that he's running against Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic Leader — and his pitch to colleagues was essentially that the guy who's been steering the ship deserves the blame for the iceberg.

"It's now on us to meet this moment, and to do that we need new leadership," Van Hollen said. "This is not about any one person."

It is absolutely about one person.

Schumer has led Senate Democrats for years through both majority and minority stints, and the résumé at this point reads like a series of increasingly expensive losses. Democrats couldn't hold the Senate. They couldn't retake the House. The midterms were supposed to be the course correction, and instead the party got handed another receipt. Van Hollen looked at that wreckage and apparently decided somebody should answer for it — and that somebody shouldn't be him.

The Maryland senator framed his challenge in the familiar language of populist reinvention. "In this election, the American people called for change," Van Hollen said. "They called for a change from Donald Trump's disastrous policies — but even bigger than that, a change from the status quo that isn't working for working people."

Notice the construction. The voters rejected the status quo — and Van Hollen is part of the status quo. He's been in the Senate since 2017. He voted with Schumer's caucus on virtually everything. But somehow the leadership failure stops at Schumer's desk and doesn't touch the senators who followed him there. According to Just the News, several incoming senators — including Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed — urged Van Hollen to make the challenge. So the reinforcements haven't even been sworn in yet and they're already picking sides in a fight over who lost harder.

Van Hollen insists this is about "answering the call of the American people." The American people called for something, all right. They called for it in November. It wasn't Chris Van Hollen.

No other Democrat has stepped forward to challenge Schumer, which means this is currently a two-man race for the privilege of leading a diminished minority. The winner gets to stand at a podium and explain why Democrats will definitely win next time with the exact same policy menu that just got rejected — again.

The real story isn't whether Van Hollen can topple Schumer. It's that the challenge is happening in public at all. Senate leadership fights usually happen behind closed doors, with polite phone calls and quiet vote counts. Van Hollen went to the press. He issued a statement. He made it a story. That's not how you unseat a leader you respect. That's how you tell the caucus the emperor has no clothes and dare them to disagree.

Schumer built his career on discipline — keeping the caucus together, keeping the messaging tight, keeping the internal disagreements out of the headlines. That discipline just failed its first post-midterm test before the new Congress has even convened.

Van Hollen's opening argument is that Democrats need to be the party of working people. His closing argument will need to explain why a senator from one of the wealthiest states in the country is the man to deliver that message. Median household income in Maryland sits above $90,000. The working-class rebrand is going to be a tough sell from Bethesda.

Schumer hasn't responded publicly. The man who spent two decades as the face of Senate Democrats is watching a colleague from his own party call him the problem — on camera, on the record, with the new class already lining up behind the challenger.

The vote hasn't been scheduled yet.


Most Popular

Most Popular