In October 2020, a University of Maryland student was accused of sexual assault. He sat through a five-day hearing before the Office of Civil Rights and Sexual Misconduct. Forensic testing contradicted the allegations. The accuser's credibility was, according to court records, "significantly undermined."
He was cleared. And then the university punished him anyway.
The student — identified as John Doe in court filings — was labeled a "rapist" and removed from the university's club lacrosse team despite the investigation finding no basis for the accusations against him. Kurt Klier, the university's Director of Club Sports, oversaw his removal. The club's own president warned others to be "very careful with what we say to" the campus sexual assault advocacy group Preventing Sexual Assault, noting "they spread information very quickly."
A federal jury just ended the five-year saga. After a week-long trial, the jury found the University of Maryland liable for deliberate indifference under Title IX — concluding the sex-based harassment Doe suffered was severe enough to deny him equal access to education, as reported by The College Fix.
"Today, after a week long jury trial, and five years of litigation, a Maryland jury found the University liable," said Jared Roberts, one of Doe's attorneys. His co-counsel Jason Greaves called it "a powerful moment, and an important result for falsely accused men everywhere."
Doe originally sought $10 million in damages. The jury awarded $1 in nominal damages — a number that sounds small until you understand what it represents. The verdict establishes liability. The university was wrong. The legal finding is on the record. And the university now carries a federal jury's determination that it allowed a cleared student to be harassed out of campus life because administrators couldn't be bothered to act.
The university's response was predictably bland. "The University of Maryland disagrees with, but nonetheless respects, the decision of the jury," a spokesperson told The College Fix. The Maryland Office of the Attorney General represented the school.
Jonathan Turley, the George Washington University law professor, noted the case "raises a long-standing complaint that universities enforce speech and anti-discrimination laws in manifestly biased ways." He added that "administrators often appear unmotivated and inert when conservatives are harassed or attacked."
The pattern is familiar by now. Title IX offices that function as conviction machines, where the process is the punishment and the outcome of the investigation is irrelevant to the outcome of your life on campus. Doe was cleared by the university's own system — the system designed to protect accusers — and it still wasn't enough to stop administrators from treating him like a guilty man.
The formal lawsuit was filed in April 2022. Five years from accusation to vindication. Five years during which a student who was cleared of every allegation had to fight the institution that cleared him.
The jury awarded one dollar. The university earned every penny of it.