Virginia Voters Just Wrote Abortion Up to Birth Into Their Constitution, After $5 Million Made Sure They Would

0
Virginia Voters Just Wrote Abortion Up to Birth Into Their Constitution, After $5 Million Made Sure They Would

At 9:01 Tuesday night, the Associated Press called Question 1 in Virginia with about 63% of the vote counted.

Abortion is now a constitutional right in the state, and one doctor's opinion is all it takes to perform one in the third trimester.

The ballot language read like a pamphlet from a pediatrician's waiting room. It listed prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, miscarriage management and fertility care. Abortion was tucked into the middle of the list, and the rest of the list didn't need a constitutional amendment.

Until Tuesday, Virginia allowed abortion through roughly 27 to 28 weeks, the end of the second trimester. After that, three physicians had to sign off: the treating doctor plus two consulting doctors. All three had to agree that continuing the pregnancy would likely kill the woman, or would "substantially and irremediably impair" her mental or physical health.

Question 1 drops the two consulting doctors. Under the amendment, the state can't stop an abortion after viability if a single physician decides, in their "professional judgment," that it's needed to protect the woman's life, physical health or mental health.

The mental health exception survives, and only one person has to sign off on it. Abortion opponents point out that this combination allows a third-trimester abortion for almost any reason a willing doctor will write down.

"The most insidious threat to our right to pass the laws needed to protect women and their children," said Olivia Gans Turner of the Virginia Society for Human Life. She called it a measure "dressed up as a legitimate measure in innocuous language that hides the full effect," and said it is "not about protecting women's safe reproductive care."

The people who paid for it seem to agree. Abortion groups spent as much as $5 million to pass Question 1. Money like that doesn't show up for miscarriage management, which no one in Virginia was trying to ban.

It shows up for the line the legislature can no longer touch. A law can be repealed next session by a new majority or a new governor. A constitutional amendment stays put no matter who wins the next election.

The Guttmacher Institute, the research arm of the abortion-rights movement, has been plain about what happens next. Amendments like this one "do not automatically repeal restrictions, and litigation is often needed to overturn them," it says. Advocates "have used these new protections as a legal basis to expand abortion access."

So the amendment is only the first step, and the lawsuits come next. Virginia's parental involvement laws, which Guttmacher itself lists as a restriction, are an obvious early target.

Virginia isn't starting from scratch, either. Abortions in the state jumped nearly 114% between 2020 and 2025, partly from women traveling in from other states.

The fight isn't over. A hearing is set for November 13 on an effort to block certification. The challengers argue the ballot question was materially misleading to voters. Given that the word "abortion" was surrounded by childbirth and fertility care, they have a case.

Until that hearing, the vote stands. Virginia used to require three doctors to sign off on a third-trimester abortion, and once the amendment is certified it will take one.


Most Popular

Most Popular